What Adam Smith Would Say About the Upcoming Elections?

Written on:October 28, 2014
Comments
Add One

Adam Smith, author of The Wealth of Nations, is mistakenly depicted by most right-wing economic commentators and economists as the cheerleader for free markets, anti-regulation advocate and a proponent for the triumph of selfishness in the marketplace.

Unfortunately, this is all wrong.

Adam Smith

Adam Smith

The upcoming elections in which Republicans may win enough seats to control the U.S Senate and push through their laissez faire, pro-corporate and privatization agenda, relies heavily on this intentional misrepresentation of Smith’s political-economic philosophy.

Betting that the average voter would succumb to misinformation and intentionally vote against their own economic self-interests, Republicans have perpetuated the Adam Smith revisionist theory as being another highly-regarded economist who hates government regulation, taxation, welfare, unions, and equal rights.

Unfortunately, since the Adam Smith brand has passed into the public domain (he died in 1790), no one can correct the propagandizing of his work today.

So with that in mind, here is what Smith wrote about the connection between wealth and societal and personal happiness, ideas which dominated the bulk of his theoretical work as seen in The Theory of Moral Sentiments, (published 1759), a book he revised six times.

The Pursuit of Happiness

Smith began teaching as a moral philosopher at Glasgow University in 1748, which pre-dates the advent of economics. As a philosopher, he addressed the role of human self-interests, the blind pursuit of wealth and how humans (as social, thinking animals) derive happiness in society. As Edward Kleinbard writes in We Are Better Than This, Smith “expected adults to have a strong ethical compass and a commitment to the happiness and tranquility of the entirety of the society in which they lived.”

These ideas are omnipresent in his best-known work, The Wealth of Nations (1776), and were never jettisoned in favor of “the invisible hand” (a deux ex machina idea that he only mentioned three times in all of his written works, according to Kleinbard ) and anti-state sentiments. Kleinbard also notes that Smith’s use of the “invisible hand” refers to God (“the Author of nature”) and dovetails with Smith’s view that societal happiness and mutual prosperity of all citizens is God’s intent.

As a philosopher, Smith incorporated ideas which are not present in today’s economic discussions. He addressed income inequality when he wrote: “No society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far greater part of the members are poor and miserable.” (Book One, Chapter 8)  In contrast, happiness is considered an “externality,” and with a few exceptions, is not mentioned in political-economic policy discussions, since it is considered soft and does not fit into an Excel spreadsheet.

He also foresaw the need for advancing local trade and employment more than international trade; and, as such, became perhaps the first critic of off-shoring, and by extrapolation, evading domestic corporate taxation.

So as we enter the last week before mid-term elections, and the Republicans elevate economic self interest, privatization, anti-regulation, anti-benefits programs, and institutionalized income inequality, let them do it without mentioning any connection to Adam Smith. The man deserves to have his pro-happiness and economic equality reputation unscathed by opportunists.

Ebola Hospital Mistakes Detailed by Texas Nurses

Written on:October 17, 2014
Comments
are closed
Ebola Hospital Mistakes Detailed by Texas Nurses

The mistakes at the Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas were due to professional and cultural lapses that put nurses and the public in danger.  Based on first-hand reports from nurses who worked at the the Dallas hospital, here are the mistakes the hospital made even when it was reported to them by staff and family that the patient, Eric Duncan, may have contracted Ebola. Worse, the nurses who brought…

Read more...

Public Should Thank Nurses Union For Raising Ebola Concerns

Written on:October 17, 2014
Comments
are closed
Public Should Thank Nurses Union For Raising Ebola Concerns

Since the first patient died of Ebola on U.S. soil, nurses and doctors have been on the front lines of treating this deadly virus. But it took the virus’ unfortunate spread to Nina Pham, a nurse attending the stricken Ebola patient, to shake up the protocol and alert the nation that there were problems in the way Texas Health Presbyterian Hospital in Dallas, as well as the Center for Disease…

Read more...

Are Country Club Homes a Bad Investment?

Written on:September 25, 2014
Comments
are closed
Are Country Club Homes a Bad Investment?

Six years after one of the worst US recessions began and its devastating impact on the housing market, one of the least scrutinized segments of the housing industry is still limping along, hampered by falling prices and slower sales. Surprisingly, it is not among middle-class communities, but in manicured and expensively maintained and  exclusive, gated country club communities. An informal survey of country club homes in Palm Beach County, which…

Read more...

Money and Race Help Too-Big-To-Fail Bank CEOs Escape Jail While Rap Artists Get Jailed

Written on:September 13, 2014
Comments
are closed
Remy Ma goes to jail as bank CEOs go free

The American justice system is clearly in trouble and here is a stark example of the gap between rich and poor, white and black,  European vs. U.S. street culture and how this strange mix all came to be co-exist.  This situation is an object lesson about the Two Americas which simultaneously exist in parallel universes. It all has to do with how the power associated with the too-big-to fail Wall…

Read more...

Beware the Terrorism-Industry Complex

Written on:September 9, 2014
Comments
are closed
Beware the Terrorism-Industry Complex

“Don’t believe what you read in the newspapers.  See, that’s the law talking.  They want us to look big so they can look bigger when they catch us.” –Warren Beatty to Faye Dunaway in “Bonnie and Clyde,” 1967 Terrorism has used violence to shape political goals since the first century, but the scope of counter-terrorism has never been greater—or more expensive—than what has evolved in the U.S. since Sept. 11,…

Read more...

The False Premise of Retirement Planning

Written on:August 29, 2014
Comments
are closed
The False Premise of Retirement Planning

The financial media is replete with articles about why more Americans are failing to accumulate enough wealth for retirement.  There are many seemingly viable answers, but the problem is that they all come from the monolithic perspective of the financial services industry: investment firms, banks, financial planners, investment counselors and corporate human resources departments. These people have a vested interest in managing this critical conversation to benefit their own products,…

Read more...

Millenials Want Social Security Benefits to Remain At Current Levels, Pew Research Finds

Written on:July 2, 2014
Comments
are closed
Millenials Want Social Security Benefits to Remain At Current Levels, Pew Research Finds

While Social Security has become a political football in Washington, Americans still regard it as the corner stone of their retirement and are very concerned about it future financial health. A Pew Research Center for the People & the Press report, the Millenials in Adulthood report, found just 14 percent of Americans expect to receive their full benefits, while an earlier Pew study found that among young people this concern…

Read more...

Food Trade Associations Missing Biggest Marketing Opportunity of the Century: The Legalization of Marijuana

Written on:June 29, 2014
Comments
are closed
Food Trade Associations Missing Biggest Marketing Opportunity of the Century: The Legalization of Marijuana

Students of history know that the most powerful idea is one whose time has come.  And that is why some of the nation’s largest food trade associations have entirely missed the boat on an emerging trend which has huge profitability written all over it. The vast opportunity, the equivalent of the “Go West Young Man” slogan which opened the American West, is the current effort to legalize marijuana.  The legalization…

Read more...

The Marijuana Industry Should Become the Newest Gem in Social Investing

Written on:June 23, 2014
Comments
are closed
The Marijuana Industry Should Become the Newest Gem in Social Investing

Social responsible investing (SRI) is defined as the investment process in which “investors weigh the social and financial returns they expect from an investment in different ways. They will often accept lower financial returns in order to generate greater social impact.” Another more upbeat definition is: “SRI is an alternative investment philosophy and strategy seeks to encourage responsible behaviors, including those supporting positive environmental practices, human rights, religious views or what is…

Read more...
Breaking News :